2. You have to be cruel to be kind


SECTION I (pp. 25-33)

Focus on: reversals

ANALYSE THE EFFECTS . . .

           'Destruction — is difficult .. . Creation, as I said, is no trouble at all' (p. 26). Analyse the comic effects Amis creates to illustrate this idea on pp. 26—8.

           Read the conversation on pp. 28—9, first as it is written, then in reverse. The claim that Friendly changed his name and 'ran' ties in with references to guilt earlier in the narrative. This detail draws our attention to the irony that is alive throughout a reversed narrative: the reader must continually re-evaluate 'earlier' incidents in the face of 'later' events which throw light on them by explaining what caused them, and so put them in a clearer perspective.

Focus on: chaos and order

EXPLORE THE IMPLICATIONS . . .

           There are accidents, sure, and yet it all works out. The city streams and pours in this symphony of trust' (p. 30). These sentences present images of chaos giving way to order. What are the implications if the process is reversed?

           Words make plain sense' (p. 32). Explore the idea that this narrative is an exercise in making the 'plain' sense of words complicated.

Focus on: the process of ‘youthing’

INTERPRET ...

          Friendly moves out of a 'morally neutral' (p. 30) old age into vigour, which the narrator associates with cruelty, 'which is bright-eyed, which is pink-tongued ...' (p. 31). In what ways does this subversion of the cliche of the undesirable ageing process provoke a fresh perspective?

 

SECTION 2 (pp. 33-56)

Focus on: irony

LOOK FOR EXAMPLES . . .

           The narrator observes Friendly's activities uncomprehend- ingly: an irony is set up between-what he misunderstands and what the reader fully understands. This means that the reader can judge what the narrator cannot. Look over this section and find examples of this irony.

Focus on: power

CONNECT IDEAS AND EXPLORE ...

           'I was flooded by thoughts and feelings I'd never had before. To do with power' (p. 45). Look at earlier and later comments about power: The devil has something to be said for him: he acts on his own initiative and isn't just following orders' (p. 17); 'Sometimes [Friendly] glows with great power, which rushes out and solves and clears everything: a power lent by the tutelary maker who presides over all his sleep' (p. 37). About his dreams he says, 'I wish I had power, just power enough to avert my eyes' (p. 48). Explore the idea of power in this section.

DISCUSS . . .

           'It seems to me that you need a lot of courage, or a lot of something, to enter into others, into other people' (pp. 46-7). If it doesn't take courage, but something else, what is that 'some¬thing?

Focus on: dreams

ANALYSE THE TENSION . . .

           The narrator has 'an intractable presentiment that I will soon start seeing ... in Tod's dream' (p. 47), something about 'vanished' babies - something that 'Tod will eventually do' (and has therefore already done). In this order of reality, dreams that are for Friendly the crucible of memories are for the nar¬rator nightmare premonitions of what will certainly happen. Analyse the effects of the tension between Friendly's under¬standing and the narrator's.

           Look at the description of Friendly's dream about babies on pp. 53-5. Analyse the way in which this episode brings together contrasting ideas.

Focus on: metaphor

INFER ...

           What point is the narrator making about Friendly's 'cen¬tral mistake about human bodies' (p. 48)?

ASK YOURSELF . . .

           On pp. 49-51, the narrator talks of Friendly's prejudice and confusion and danger. Then he describes the insane logic of the reversed world. Which is more confused?

Focus on: attitudes to women

ANALYSE . . .

           Analyse the attitudes to women expressed on pp. 55-6. Whose are they: Friendly's or the narrator's?

 

SECTION 3 (pp. 57-73)

Focus on: context

RESEARCH CONTEXT . . .

           The narrative is set in 1970 at this point. Look up what was happening at that time in a chronicle of the twentieth century. What details has Amis selected, and what has he left out? What effects are created by the details he has included?

Focus on: irony

ANALYSE WITH CLOSE READING . . .

           Analyse what the passage on pp. 57-9 implies about iden¬tity and conscience, and analyse how it implies this.

           Analyse what the passages on pp. 59-63 and 65-6 convey about Friendly's motives for his relationships with women.

NOTE THE EXAMPLES . . .

           There are a number of details in this section which are not explained. They point forward ironically to events that gave rise to them and which will be explained later. Make a note of these details as they arise.

Looking over Chapter 2

QUESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION

1.            Evaluate the claim that, at this stage in the novel, the conceit of the reversal of time amounts to little more than ingenious wordplay.
2.            What bearing does the title of this chapter have on the chapter itself?

3.            Comment on the relationship between Tod Friendly and the narrator.