5. Here there is no why


SECTION 1 (pp. 124-35)

Focus on: the power of a name

EVALUATE YOUR RESPONSE ...

'Auschwitz' is first mentioned on p. 124. How do you react to this name? What connotations does it carry?

RESEARCH AND PRESENT . . .

           What do you know of the real Auschwitz? Do some research. You might look at the Auschwitz museum at http://www.auschwitz-muzeum.oswiecim.pl/html/. If you are in a group, it might be useful to discuss and combine your knowledge.

ANALYSE ...

           Analyse the sentence, Auschwitz lay around me ... like a somersaulted Vatican' (p. 124). What other Roman Catholic images figure, and to what effect?

           What does 'preternatural purpose' (pp. 124, 127, 128) mean to the narrator? Linked to the title of this chapter, what does it mean to you? 

Focus on: cross-references

CONNECT AND PREDICT . . .

           Connect the image of Unverdorben donning black boots and white coat with previous allusions to this image '(e.g., pp. 12, 48, 72). Given these and other clues that have been trailed throughout the novel, predict what Unverdorben's crime has been.

Focus on: irony and knowledge

TRACE AND REACT ...

           The inversion of Young's life as a doctor finds a shockingly dark counterpoint here. Trace the ironies on pp. 126—35, and gauge your reactions to them. These ironies depend on our having a greater knowledge of what is really happening than the narrator. In what sense does this technique highlight the collective human loss of innocence that the Holocaust brought about?

Focus on: beauty and ugliness

ANALYSE THE LANGUAGE . . .

           Look at the description of the doctor, 'Uncle Pepi', who was 'coldly beautiful, true, with self-delighted eyes; graceful, chasteningly graceful in his athletic authority' (p. 127). What ironic effects are created by these words in this context?

RECONCILE ...

           Bearing the above in mind, can you reconcile the 'quest for greater elegance' (p. 128) among the guards at Auschwitz with what they do?

Focus on: coprocentricity

COMPARE . . .

           Why is there an emphasis on human faeces? Part IV of  Jonathan Swift's Gulliver's Travels,  a satire on the society of the day, was also full of it. Philip Pinkus, in Sin and Satire in Swift (1965), writes:

"Since Swift's constant concern in his satires is man's corruption from original innocence, there is no more graphic illustration than the excremental. That is why his satires are obsessed with it. It is the traditional imagery of evil, of which Swift's contemporaries were well aware [...} All Swift's references to the unclean flesh, the dung, the stench, the filth of man's body, are the symbols of man's sin."

Does excrement have a symbolic function here? If so, what does it symbolise?

SECTION 2 (pp. 135-45)

Focus on: 'the bomb baby'

INTERPRET THE SYMBOL ...

           The narrator has alluded throughout to the 'bomb baby' that exerts 'such power over its parents' (p. 135), and 'the mortal importance of no one knowing they are there' (p. 101). See also references to this idea on pp. 48, 55, 67. What does this dream image seem to symbolise? Make what sense of it you can. It will be more clearly explained later. What effects are created by these orders of unexplained images?

Focus on: insane perspectives

COMPARE . . .

           The narrator's inverted perspective has created a gap between what he says and what we understand. What he sees as creative magic, we know to be a delirious account of insane destruction. But when Herta confronts Unverdorben about ugly truths, the narrator's delusional system of thought goes into overdrive, using insane inversions to justify atrocities. He sees time backwards, of course, and cannot see straight: but by this stage, is there anything to distinguish the insanity of the narrator's inverted perspective from that of Unverdorben, or 'Uncle Pepi', or any of the others who inhabit the world of forward time and are guilty of the crimes that are described? Compare the delusional thought systems of the narrator and of his human counterpart, Unverdorben.

Focus on: Uncle Pepi'

COMMENT ...

           What more do we learn about 'Uncle Pepi' in this section?

Consider in particular the details that frame his portrait on pp. 136 and 144-5.

RESEARCH . . .

— Research the historical figure of Josef Mengele. Is 'Uncle  Pepi' a fictionalised portrait of this man?